
A
Piece of Canada's Past
History
buffs say Pickering site was home to a big Seneca village but
officials won't acknowledge it
Jerry Amernic
Special To The Star
Elizabeth
Shumovich remembers when her husband was ploughing their garden
in 1968 and found a cannonball. They had just bought a property
east of the Rouge River in Pickering. He found it in the soil
at the back of the lot. It was about the size of a small potato.
Rusty, weat herbeaten and heavy.
She
says her husband grew up in south Pickering and told her about
the old Indian village at the mouth of the Rouge. Over the years
they found other things - flint and arrowheads - but the "Shumovich
cannonball," as the locals call it, was the prize catch.
Local
resident Marian Martin, a real estate agent who spends her spare
time dabbling in history, thinks she knows how it got there. She
says there was an old Seneca village at the mouth of the Rouge,
on the hill over looking the east bank. It was an ideal spot,
with open access to Lake Ontario, a navigable river that led north
to Lake Simcoe (making it a prime fur-trading route) and high
ground that was a natural fortification.
The
village, Martin says, was a thriving community with longhouses
and acres of cornfields. It was called Ganatsekwyagon, and in
the late 1600s , was home to many Seneca.
The Seneca
were the most numerous of the Six Nations of the Iroquois, and
Lake Ontario was ringed with their villages. But in the summer
of 1687, the French, trying to gain a foothold in the fur trade,
razed all those villages in one swoop. They had guns. And cannonballs.
New York
state has preserved an old Seneca village near Rochester. The
Ganondagan State Historic Site was formally dedicated on July
14, 1987, which, according to the museum there, was 300 years
to the day after the governor-general of New France destroyed
the village. New York also recognizes another Seneca village,
Gandagora, as a historic site.
Ganatsekwyagon?
In Canada there is no official recognition.
Enter www.blackhole.ca.
If ever there was a Web site prepared for battle, it's this
one, run by Martin. She has spent years doing research and has
found maps. The 1656 Samson map has the village. So do the 1670
Galinee map, 1673 Jolliet map and 1688 Ruffeix map. She also
found a 1793 sketch from David Smith, first surveyor general
of Upper Canada, with the words "old Indian field" written east
of the river.
And she
unearthed an 1885 account of the village from historian C. Blackett
Robinson, and a reference in a 1933 book, Toronto During
The French Regime, by Percy Robinson.
Martin says
Ganatsekwyagon was one of the first recorded residences of white
men in the Toronto area - missionaries who arrived in 1668.
It had the first school and was the first trading centre.
"Ontario
has no legislation to protect important historic sites from
development," Martin says. "By world heritage standards, the
Ontario Heritage Act is badly obsolete."
Lionel Purcell,
82, is president of the Scarborough Historical Society. He recalls
being given Indian artifacts in the 1940s by Gerald Cowan, whose
farm was just east of the Rouge River.
"I don't
have any question about that village," says Purcell.
He says
the Rouge and Humber were the only rivers in the Toronto area
that went north to Lake Simcoe. Another Seneca village called
Teiaiagon, which was at the mouth of the Humber, is recognized.
David Redwolf
says he is descended from Mohawk leader Joseph Brant (1742-1807)
and Seneca Chief Red Jacket (1758-1830) and can trace his roots
to Teiaiagon. He says Ganat sekwyagon was the largest Seneca
village in Canada and may have been home to up to 3,300 people.
What's more,
he says that when the French burned the villages, a fire-storm
swept through what is now mainland Toronto and for the next
50 years, the area was a "no-man's land." He says this explains
why trees on the Toronto Islands are larger than those on the
mainland.
"Ganatsekwyagon
is a focal point of Canadian history," Redwolf says. "There is
no doubt about the village."
He speaks
of " the total desecration" of his people and their land, and
says Ganatsekwyagon is historically important not only to the
First Nations, but to all Canadians.
At least
some of the area that Martin, Redwolf and others claim to be
the site of Ganatsekwyagon is on land owned by the Toronto Region
Conservation Authority.
In 1988,
it produced an archeological survey that mentions a Seneca site
called Bead Hill upstream from the mouth of the Rouge. Bead
Hill was later designated by Canada's National Historic Sites
and Monuments Act.
"The survey
involved test pits and no substantial number of artifacts was
found at the mouth of the Rouge," notes Malcolm Horne, a heritage
planner with the Ontario Ministry of Culture. "We have to go
on physical evidence and there were no artifacts tying anything
there to post-1550."
But
Redwolf says Ganatsek wyagon means "the place where the cliff
splits." He says that clearly refers to the bluffs on Lake Ontario.
He also believes a burial ground was nearby.
A spokesperson
with the province's Native Affairs Secretariat says she has
never heard of Ganatsekwyagon.
Calls
to the conservation authority resulted in an interview with a
staff archeologist who says he has no experience with the Rouge
River site.
Not to be
denied , Martin pulls out a copy of the 1-5 Conceptual Plan,
South Rosebank Area, prepared by the Metropolitan Toronto and
Region Waterfront Plan. (That makes it a conservation authority
document.) Page four refers to "the historic importance of the
Rouge River mouth as the site of a major Indian settlement -
Ganatsekwyagon."
Martin smirks
with satisfaction.
"Ganatsekwyagon
has been waiting for centuries to be recognized," she says. "To
the day I die, I'll be convinced it was here."
Jerry
Amernic of Toronto is the author of Gift Of The Bambino and is
at work on a novel about the legacy of the Iroquois.